BIAS REARTI
MAIN CONT LINK ORDER CRED HIST NEWS

Introduction

The Manitoba Indian Brotherhood: forerunner of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs released in 1976 a study entitled The Shocking Truth about Indians in textbooks.  The study reviewed Manitoba approved public school textbooks. Depiction of indigenous people and the inaccurate history found in the approved textbooks appalled and shocked everyone involved in the research. 

Sadly: twenty-three years later many of the poor uninformed and misinformed children who were instructed in the stereotypical books havent upgraded their information. Today; students who were taught using those textbooks are adults; many are in positions of authority, people with the power to impact upon the lives of First Nations people.

Judges, crown attorneys, police officers, lawyers, doctors, politicians, government officials, journalists and anyone else (including natives) who went to school in Manitoba were all unknowingly schooled in racism.  Bias by omission is a euphemism for racism.  It is racism not by intend but by lack of information. In the introduction the authors warn, "If a student encounters in his studies, material which is derogatory toward a race of people, he will undoubtedly adopt these same attitudes, probably for life." Once ingrained, opinions formed in children are hard to change as they become adults. There has to be some motivation to change that opinion.

In 1983 the Winnipeg Sun, a major Winnipeg newspaper published an opinion by Peter Warren in which he stated, "the average Canadian Indian is a drunk, a wastrel, an idolmonger, a person only too happy to live on a government cheque, an inbreeder, a parasite, a non contributor."  Warren was a long time radio talk show host with CJOB, the highest rated radio talk show in Manitoba. Racism however is rarely blatant, it generally so subtle and pervasive that most individuals dont realize that it is racism. 

In the Shocking Truth about Indians in textbooks, ten criteria was used to evaluate historical information: 

  • Bias by Omission: selecting information that reflects credit on only one group, frequently the writers group.
     
  • Bias by Defamation: calling attention to the native persons faults rather than his virtues and misrepresenting his nature.
     
  • Bias by Disparagement: (disparagement: something that lowers a thing or person in worth or importance): denying or belittling the contributions of native people to Canadian culture.
     
  • Bias by Cumulative Implication: constantly creating the impression that only one group is responsible for positive developments.
     
  • Bias by (lack of) Validity: failing to ensure that information about issues is always accurate and unambiguous.  (Ambiguous: having more than one possible meaning.)
     
  • Bias by Inertia: perpetuation of legends and half-truths by failure to keep abreast of historical scholarship.
     
  • Bias by Obliteration: ignoring significant aspects of native history.
     
  • Bias by Disembodiment: referring in a casual and depersonalized way to the Indian menace or representing the annihilation of Indian culture as part of the march of progress.
     
  • Bias by (lack of) Concreteness: dealing with a race or group in platitudes and generalizations (applying the shortcomings of one individual to a whole group). To be concrete, the material must be factual, objective and realistic.
     
  • Bias by (lack of) Comprehensiveness: failing to mention all relevant facts that may help to form the opinion of the student.

The content of grades four, five and six textbooks was examined.  Social studies, (history) curriculum of children in the schools were analyzed.  These children generally ten, eleven and twelve years of age;  were in the prime years for formation of self-image. Use of adjectives cannot be ignored in conveying meaning. In the study, use of word association with Europeans or Indians clearly conveyed image. For example:

Use of Positive Adjectives:                             

Use of Negative Adjectives:                          

Word

Europeans

Indians

Word

Europeans

Indians

           

Great

123

15

Savage

8

16

Good

79

5

Hostile

4

30

Successful

70

5

Squaw

0

20

Brave

67

5

Raiding

24

18

Gentleman

66

0

Massacre

4

13

Strong

64

10

Drunk

10

11

Honorable

52

3

Howling

3

11

Courageous

47

0

Unfriendly

4

11

Determined

46

5

Warlike

6

10

           

Totals:

614

48

Totals:

63

140

Part III of the study lists 306 adjectives, which were used in the textbooks and have a negative or positive effect upon the reader. The 1976 students who came through the public school system in Manitoba would now be between 33 to 35 years of age. Everyone over the age of 35 was schooled using the same type of textbooks, but that is not to say that everyone under 33 got the benefit of an informed or improved curriculum.  So what is the results?  Has racism taught in Manitoba public schools had an impact?

stretcher
topbutton backbutton
bak1